The potential for integrating Sentinel 2 MSI with SPOT 5 HRG and Landsat 8 OLI imagery for monitoring semi-arid savannah woody cover

Abstract

Multitemporal archived imagery enables the monitoring of savannah woody cover, for ecological purposes. Compatibility in multitemporal, multiple sensor image data would facilitate the monitoring. The decommissioning of SPOT 5 (Système Pour l'Observation de la Terre 5) left a void in multispectral imagery at the 10 m spatial resolution of its high-resolution geometric (HRG) sensor. The subsequent launch of Sentinel 2 presented an opportunity for data continuity to monitor the savannah woody cover, using equivalent 10 m resolution multispectral instrument (MSI) bands. This study examined the integration potential of Sentinel 2 MSI with the longer archive HRG and Landsat 8 (Land Satellite 8) Operational Land Imager (OLI) imagery, in assessing savannah woody cover. Images of three semi-arid savannah sites acquired on same season dates that excluded herbaceous vegetation from the spectral signature were used: November 2014 (HRG) and December 2015 (MSI, OLI). Using equivalent green (G), red (R), and near infrared (NIR) bands at 10 m (MSI, HRG) and 30 m (OLI) resolution, the woody cover was mapped through subpixel classification. The mapped woody cover was compared for statistical differences using χ2 analysis at 10 m resolution (MSI, HRG) and at a degradation of the MSI and HRG images to the 30 m OLI pixel size. Conversion to top-of-atmosphere reflectance values facilitated inter-sensor correlation of G, R, and NIR reflectance for field sampling sites where woody cover was quantified. Inter-sensor regression functions in G, R, and NIR band MSI and HRG images were developed. The 10 m resolution classifications of woody cover were not statistically different. Due to spatial resolution similarity, SPOT 5 HRG multispectral imagery was established as suitable for integration with equivalent band MSI imagery in mapping the woody cover in a multitemporal analysis. For dense woody cover, Landsat 8 OLI imagery was more suitable for integration with MSI than HRG images due to higher radiometric sensitivity, which can permit monitoring physiology-related woody reflectance.