Incompatibility as a ground for dismissal in South African labour law
Loading...
Date
Authors
Researcher ID
Supervisors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
North-West University (South Africa).
Record Identifier
Abstract
Incompatibility has been broadly defined as the inability of an employee to conform to an employer's corporate culture. The employer's corporate culture governs the interpersonal relationship in the organisation. It directs the manner in which an employee must conduct his or herself in the organisation. Where the employee is unable to conform to the employer's corporate culture, or act in a way that causes disharmony in the organisation, the employer may have a justifiable reason to dismiss the employee.
The concept of incompatibility has existed in South African labour law for centuries. It was first accepted as a ground for dismissal in the 1987 case of Erasmus v BB Ltd (1987) 8 ILJ 537, where the Industrial Court held that it is justifiable for an employer to dismiss an employee who causes disharmony in the organisation. Following the decision of the above judgment, the courts and eminent scholars on this topic accepted the position that incompatibility is a valid ground for dismissal. However, the problem with incompatibility as a ground for dismissal is that, firstly, the above judgment does not set out when, how or what procedure to follow when dismissing the employee on grounds of incompatibility. Secondly, the former Labour Relations Act 28 of 1956 and the current Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 does not recognise incompatibility as a ground for dismissal. The lack of legislative guidance has created a number of problems over the years, as the employer who is faced with incompatibility in an organisation is forced to tolerate the employee who is causing the disharmony in the organisation, or worse, the employer may exercise discretion and dismiss the employee for whatever reason it deems fit, and following whatever procedure it deems fit. The effect is that the employee who is dismissed on grounds of incompatibility may refer an unfair dismissal dispute to the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA). The CCMA may reinstate the employee because the employer could not prove that the dismissal of the employee was justifiable and in accordance with fair procedures. In an attempt to bridge the gap created by a lack of legislative recognition and guidance on when, how and what procedure to follow when opting to dismiss the employee on
grounds of incompatibility, the courts over the years have established characteristic features of justifiable reasons to dismiss the employee on grounds of incompatibility. The courts have also characterised incompatibility as a form of incapacity. It is submitted that incompatibility is subjective and therefore it is best categorised as a form of incapacity. Although the courts have accepted that incompatibility is best categorised as a form of incapacity, they have also accepted the employer's categorisation of incompatibility as a form of misconduct or the employer's operational requirements provided that the employer can prove that the dismissal on grounds of incompatibility falls with the chosen category and a fair procedure has been followed. It is submitted that by accepting the employer's categorisation of incompatibility as a form of misconduct or the employer's operational requirements, the courts have created more uncertainties as the employer may continue to exercise discretion and deal with the incompatibility in a form and manner it deems fit.
The courts have further provided guidance that the employer may follow when opting to dismiss the employee on grounds of incompatibility. The guidance provided by the courts ensures that the dismissal of the employee on grounds of incompatibility is substantively and procedurally fair. Although the courts have categorised incompatibility as a form of incapacity and have provided guidance thereto, this study argues that there is a need for the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1996 and the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal to recognise incompatibility as a ground for dismissal, and to provide guidance for employers in this regard. This study argues that the recognition of incompatibility as a ground for dismissal in the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 is essential to dealing with incompatibility disputes in the future. It could also go a long way in ensuring certainty and uniformity in the processes that should be followed in dealing with incompatibility as a ground for dismissal.
Sustainable Development Goals
Description
LLM (Labour Law), North-West University, Potchefstroom Campus
