Misplacing nema? A consideration of some problematic aspects of South Africa's new EIA regulations
Abstract
In mid-2006, new Regulations governing environmental impact assessment were
published in terms of the National Environmental Management Act 107 of 1998. It is
argued in this article that the old Regulations under the Environment Conservation
Act 73 of 1989, which were replaced, had proved inadequate not because of any
inherent deficiency, but because they were never properly implemented and
because they were instead subjected to much inaccurate criticism. The article then
canvasses the old Regulations and considers criticisms thereof, before canvassing
the new Regulations and assessing differences between the old and the new.
Various specific concerns and potential shortcomings are raised and considered;
and various interpretations are offered of problematic provisions. A prognosis for the
success and/or failure of the new Regulations is then put forward in the context of
the South African government's present approach to economic growth,
environmental protection and the enforcement of environmental legislation. Finally, it
is argued that there are danger signs that the new Regulations will be as
misunderstood and misapplied as were the old Regulations and that the fundamental
principles of the National Environmental Management Act are likely not to be
adhered to in the implementation of the new Regulations.
Collections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Fulfilment of South Africa's constitutional environmental right in the local government sphere
Du Plessis, Alida Anél (North-West University, 2008)Claims related to the environment increasingly permeate the domain of human and fundamental rights. It is widely accepted that a direct functional relationship exists between the pursuit of environmental aims generally, ... -
The implementation and enforcement of the legal environmental health mandate in South Africa
Erasmus, Lourens Johannes (North-West University (South Africa), 2023)The environment is a vital determinant of the human condition. In South Africa many people's health, well-being, and quality of life suffer from environmental health hazards. Over the last two decades government adopted ... -
The regulation of acid mine drainage in South Africa: law and governance perspectives
Feris, Loretta; Kotzé, Louis J (2014)Acid mine drainage (AMD) is arguably one of the most serious environmental concerns in South Africa. AMD is a legacy left behind by abandoned, derelict and defunct mines, and is a continuing by-product of existing mining ...