Die aanspreeklikheid van kopers van bates uit 'n insolvente boedel vir die omgewingsaanspreeklikheid van die insolvente verkoper: Lesse van die VSA
Abstract
Where the environmental law and the insolvency law come up against each other in a
given situation, a heated debate still continues over whether and to what extent the debtor
can and should be able to fulfil its obligations to clean up, remedy, avoid, limit injury, to
pay for the costs thereof or to pay for past harms to the environment. How do the provisions
of the insolvency law and the Insolvency Act affect or influence a debtor’s environmental
obligations? How do the provisions of the environmental laws affect or influence
the provisions of the Insolvency Act? The reality is that the mere prospect of possible
“survivor” environmental liabilities may frustrate a company’s successful business rescue
or substantially reduce and delay the creditors’ recovery in the event of liquidation or
sequestration. Should there be huge environmental obligations linked to the property, the
trustee or liquidator would simply not be able to sell it. In this investigation, the liability
of purchasers of property (ie successors in property), where expensive environmental
obligations exist in respect of the asset concerned, is discussed. In American insolvency
law, section 363 of the Bankruptcy Code is applied to block successor liability, including
the liability for environmental obligations. After an analysis of some American cases in
this area, it is recommended that the same principle be applied in South Africa, but due to
the fact that this is about circumstances and injuries that affect and harm the lives and
health of people – people that in the present-day conditions of modern industrialisation
cannot protect themselves – very strict requirements, as well as possible restrictions,
should be built into the process. Finally, factors which in the opinion of the author are
essentially non-negotiable for a fair conduct of the legal position are formulated
Collections
- Faculty of Law [387]