The Journal for Transdisciplinary Research in Southern Africa ISSN: (Online) 2415-2005, (Print) 1817-4434 Page 1 of 10 Original Research Considering the Basotho indigenous education and school system as resources for peace-building education in Lesotho Author: Lesotho faces political, economic, social, cultural, religious, institutional and interpersonal Rasebate I. Mokotso1,2 violence, a situation that prompted the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Affiliations: Organization (UNESCO) to introduce a peace-building education program. This indigenous 1Department of Religion auto-ethnography inquiry arose as the result of the investigator’s realisation that the UNESCO Studies, Faculty of Theology strategy to establish peace education in Lesotho is an exclusive, narrow approach based on the and Religion, University of formal Western education system. While UNESCO’s initiative to instil a culture of peace via the Free State, Bloemfontein, South Africa education is commendable considering the seriousness of the violence in Lesotho, the article contends that the approach excludes many out-of-school youth from learning about developing 2Department of Language a culture of peace. The article also reveals some characteristics associated with the Western and Social Education, Faculty educational system that contribute to its inability to incorporate all eligible groups in peace- of Education, National University of Lesotho, Roma, building education. Guided by the theoretical framework of critical interculturality, this article Lesotho highlighted the Basotho lebollo education system as having the ability to extend peace-building education beyond the confines of Western schooling and education to include out-of-school Corresponding author: adolescents. The compatibility of the lebollo school system with peace-building education was Rasebate Mokotso, rasebatemokotso@gmail. proved by its indigenous epistemology and pedagogy. The article recommends a nonviolent com strategy devoid of colonial violence and based on mutual respect that can bring lebollo on board for peace-building education, as has happened in response to the HIV and AIDS pandemic. Dates: Received: 12 Mar. 2022 Transdisciplinarity Contribution: This paper contributes to the broad debate that Western Accepted: 09 June 2022 formal education ensnared in colonial power structures, has difficulty meeting the educational Published: 31 Aug. 2022 needs of the African child, despite its noble intentions. Using Basotho indigenous education How to cite this article: system as a framework for calling for recognition of indigenous education, the paper makes Mokotso RI. Considering the case for peacebuilding education as a potential model for indigenous education. the Basotho indigenous education and school system Keywords: Basotho; education; indigenous; interculturality; lebollo; peace. as resources for peace- building education in Lesotho. J transdiscipl res S Afr. 2022;18(1), a1213. Introduction https://doi.org/10.4102/ Currently, Lesotho is afflicted with multiple forms of violence, including direct violence, structural td.v18i1.1213 violence and cultural violence. Direct violence includes behaviour that undermines life itself and/ Copyright: or decreases one’s ability to meet basic human needs. Examples of direct violence are killing, © 2022. The Authors. maiming, bullying, sexual assault and emotional manipulation. On the other hand, structural Licensee: AOSIS. This work violence refers to the systematic denial of access to goods, services and opportunities for some is licensed under the Creative Commons groups of society. Cultural violence represents the prevailing or prominent social norms that Attribution License. make direct and structural violence seem ‘normal’, ‘just’ or at least ‘acceptable’.1 The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) responded to this situation in the country by introducing a peace-building education program. The UNESCO educational program aims at fostering peace, resilience and the avoidance of violent extremism. The project’s main objective is to teach young people about peace, global citizenship, resilience and the avoidance of violent extremism through education. As one of the African Union’s (AU’s) established agenda items, the intended objective of the initiative is to eliminate all types of wars, civil disputes, gender-based violence and violent conflicts on the continent.2 In collaboration with the Japanese government, UNESCO held seminars for teacher educators Read online: from universities and teacher training colleges, as well as secondary school teachers, as part of the Scan this QR project’s execution. The seminars were meant to increase teachers’ ability by informing and code with your smart phone or empowering them on why and how to educate for peace. Peace education aims to examine ethical mobile device issues and transformative pedagogy and offer practical tools that encourage learners to alter the to read online. world around them. Transformative pedagogy is optimised to empower both teachers and learners. http://www.td-sa.net Open Access Page 2 of 10 Original Research It is intended to enable students to become introspective and by consumers for the purpose of building ‘skill sets’ to be critical thinkers who can make a positive contribution to their used in the marketplace, rather than as a set of skills, attitudes local and global societies.2 This article wholeheartedly and values necessary for everyday life. supports UNESCO’s action, especially given the severity of the violence in Lesotho. Lesotho is currently beset with The second point of the education–employment linkage political, social, economic, cultural, religious, institutional adds to the first by increasing the number of dropouts and and interpersonal violence.3,4 However, the article argues child labour. With unemployment reaching 24% in 2019,11 against the current approach on two grounds: firstly, the affecting individuals both with and without degrees, program is focused on the formal Western schooling system. conventional schooling has gradually lost influence. Young Victims and perpetrators of domestic and cultural abuse are people are seeking alternative work and self-employment not recognised and targeted in this way. The formal Western opportunities that do not require formal education. Many education system does not serve a sizable number of Basotho young boys work as herders in order to become self- youth. As a result, the scope is narrow, and the impact is likely employed farmers in the future.10 According to recent media to be limited. Lesotho did, in fact, introduce free primary reports, a chief from the Thaba-Tseka district in Lesotho, education in 2000 and made it mandatory with the passing of which has one of the highest out-of-school child rates at 29% the Education Act of 2010.5 However, the United Nations as compared to the other nine districts, visited his villages to Children’s Fund (UNICEF)6 recorded a total of 3% out of discover why eligible children are denied access to education. school at the primary level, 14% at the lower secondary level Both the children and their parents expressed their and nearly 36% at the upper secondary level nationwide in dissatisfaction with the Western schooling system. They 2021. Also, the legal term ‘compulsory’ appears to be stated that their focus is on the expanding wool and mohair ineffective. According to Lekhetho,4 the government of farming industry, as well as the booming illegal mining Lesotho lacks the capacity to prosecute parents who do not industry in South Africa.12 Indeed, according to the Central send their children to school because of the complexities of Bank of Lesotho,13 only half of college and university the issue, which involves some cultural beliefs and practices. graduates are working, while the other half are job seekers. A sizable proportion of Basotho youth are not served by the The majority of those employed are in the low-paying private formal Western education system. sector, which does not recognise their college credentials. Second, peace education promotes and supports a culture of Based on the importance of peace-building education and the peace by teaching children, youth and adults the skills of above expressed doubts about Western formal education, the peaceful living. A culture of peace entails a set of values, author proposed expanding the scope of peace-building attitudes, behaviours and common lifestyles characterised by education by incorporating indigenous Basotho educational respect for life and human rights, avoidance of all forms of approaches. The major goal is to use an intercultural approach violence and observance of the principles of peace, such as in which global perspectives on a culture of peace are justice, tolerance, solidarity, cooperation and equality.7 Peace- taught through indigenous education systems, with the building education or education for building a culture of goal of reaching out to out-of-school children and adults. peace, according to Navarro-Castro and Nario-Galace,8 Navarro-Castro and Nario-Galace8 argue that peace-building serves to cultivate knowledge, skills, attitudes and values in education is more successful and meaningful when it is order to shape people’s mindsets towards living out peace. tailored to the social and cultural context of the country in Peace-building education, simply put, aims to create a culture which it is conducted. Indigenous education and pedagogy that reflects human nature as peaceful people. proposed in this article are strategies to tailor peace-building education congruent to the social and cultural context of However, Western education has always been associated Basotho. with preparing people for the labour market, rather than education for a life orientation. That is, the value of a child’s education is weighed against the potential for future A methodological guide employment. As Western education was introduced to Africa, In pursuant of the mentioned objectives, the author used Africans have found it particularly appealing on account of indigenous auto-ethnography. Auto-ethnography, according its economic benefits and social prestige, according to to Grist,14 differs from standard ethnography on purpose. Ukpabi.9 Western education is frequently viewed as a means Traditional ethnographers focused on recording the to an end, with the end being the acquisition of white-collar mysterious ‘Other’ by participant observation, living in close jobs that require men and women with educational proximity to indigenous peoples to observe and record that credentials. In a study of the meaning of schooling in Lesotho, behaviour new to the ‘civilised’ world. In the majority of Dungey and Ansell10 discovered that, while formal education cases, ethnographers distorted the ‘Other’ by failing to is thought to contribute to moral and physical well-being, the comprehend the indigenous culture and knowledge systems primary purpose of schooling is usually linked to economic they documented. By contrast, auto-ethnography refers to a survival. Education is seen as a key to gaining access to piece of research that looks at personal experience (auto) in formal sector jobs, which pay well and allow people to live order to understand cultural experience (graphy).15 In the comfortably. This means that education in Western school auto-ethnographic method, the researcher retroactively and systems is mainly seen as a commodity that can be purchased selectively writes about past experiences. The researcher http://www.td-sa.net Open Access Page 3 of 10 Original Research does not live through these experiences solely for research within a single nation-state. According to critical purpose; instead they are assembled using hindsight. In this interculturality, the answers to this question lie in the history article, indigenous auto-ethnography plays a particularly of colonialism, where a colonial political system existed in important role, as it allows recreation of stories that reflect which one country was conquered by a foreign power. cultural differences caused by colonialism within a state or According to Santos,19 critical interculturality exposes the ethnicity. realities of colonialism, which include cultural estrangement, self-denial and the desire to become acquainted with the This indigenous auto-ethnography was written from the superior culture, while ignoring the valuable contribution perspective of the ‘self’, that is, presenting personal experience that subaltern culture can make in addressing current national while retaining indigenous identity. Using Anderson’s auto- and global social, political and cultural formations. As an ethnography techniques, the following five steps were analytical instrument, critical interculturality enhances our followed: ‘(1) complete member researcher status (CMR), (2) awareness of the historical and structural nature of imperial, analytic reflexivity, (3) narrative visibility of the researcher’s colonial injustices that shape modern cultural diversity. identity, (4) dialogue with informants beyond oneself and (5) commitment to theoretical analysis’ (p. 378).16 In the first Critical interculturality identifies collective actors that may instance, the author played the role of an opportunistic CMR, transform asymmetrical relations by developing new being indigenous to Basotho culture. The views imparted are channels of participation and recognition. It is an attempt to essentially through long-term cultural insider experiences, not bring indigenous thinking into the space of social action. It is necessarily recorded for this particular article. Regarding the an ideological paradigm that guides indigenous social and second aspect of analytic reflexivity, The researcher invested political thinking and activity.20 As Walsh20 indicates, it is a some meanings in Basotho cultural practices. The author new critical thought for divergence from dominant culture entered into the discussion as the ‘self’ within the community and convergence with indigenous culture as one mode of of ‘others’; that is, the author reflected on the meanings of decolonisation process. Such divergence and convergence, cultural schooling and indigenous education as an insider according to Walsh,21 entails not only relativising indigenous cultural representative within the community of different culture and ideas but also enacting their political and cultures, the indigenous and Western cultures. The author decolonial character, putting them in the proper place of their maintained the third element of the visibility of the researcher’s relevance with the supposed superior culture. It necessitates self in the text by organising the discussion through experience a radical change by engaging in a process of transforming, rather than imminent recorded information, as epiphanies in reconceptualising and refounding national structures and order to disqualify the ‘normal’. The author upheld the fourth institutions in ways that put varied cultural logics, practices item of dialogue with others beyond the ‘self’ through and ways of knowing, thinking, doing, being and living in an 17 triangulating self-experiences with the literature relevant to equitable (but still conflictive) relationship. issues of discussion. The last tenet of commitment to theoretical analysis was enhanced through the use of a critical Critical interculturality served as a springboard for this interculturality analytic framework. study, which began by examining the current state of Basotho indigenous schooling and education systems, specifically Analytic and transformational why they are at a nonexistent stage in preparing Basotho for current global knowledge demands, particularly knowledge framework on how to build a culture of peace. The intention was to In this study, critical interculturality, which is compatible with locate them and bring them forward with the ultimate goal of the indigenous auto-ethnography, was applied to provide an using them in UNESCO’s planned peace education program. analytical framework. Walsh17 describes critical interculturality The reasoning derives from worries about the extent and as a different perspective from relational interculturality coverage of Western education, as well as its transformational approach. The other reason was that Basotho education was that views cross-cultural contact as a natural process of deemed to be better capable of attaining the required effects syncretism and transculturation. Critical interculturality also than Western education. All of these doubts originate from contrasts with functional interculturality in that the latter is knowledge politics or the struggle for a place and value for based on the acceptance of cultural differences and their Basotho indigenous knowledge systems, which are colonially incorporation into social structures, and it attempts to subjugated. This article is an act of activism for the ‘other’ encourage dialogue and tolerance without examining the knowledge, that is, indigenous knowledge, within epistemic origins of asymmetry and sociocultural unfairness. interculturality, with a firm trust in its ability to produce the intended outcome. Critical interculturality, according to Fleuri and Fleuri,18 concerns colonial constructs of cultural differences within a Entering the world of Basotho nation state or ethnicity. Its focus is not necessarily on ethnic and cultural diversity but cultural differences created as the indigenous education colonial power pattern infused virtually all layers of life. The world of Basotho indigenous education is the world Critical interculturality poses the question of why there is a of subaltern education, the education that suffered cultural divide between modernity and traditional cultures marginalisation, exclusion and disqualification. However, it http://www.td-sa.net Open Access Page 4 of 10 Original Research continued to survive and seek its place within the current view that schooling is the process of socialising groups of colonial order as an alternative for most indigenous people. children and young people on specific skills and values in a As early as the arrival of Western missionaries in the 1830s, society. This socialising mechanism contributes immensely to Lesotho embraced a Western schooling system that was social conformity and becomes essential glue that holds consistent with Western civilisation, culture, economics and society together.30,31 political systems.22 The existing indigenous cultural outlets, organisations and educational institutions were suppressed. Lebollo possesses these features, and it might be said that it However, they continued existing at the margins, parallel to symbolises the indigenous Basotho schooling system because Western formations. it is institutionalised and includes a set of cultural curriculum content, cultural professional teachers and a specific period The Basotho indigenous education system occurs in different and location agreed upon. This, however, does not indicate settings and uses different procedures.23 However, the author that lebollo fits the standards of the Western schooling system, proposed to enter into the Basotho education system by contrary to Matsela,23 who says that lebollo qualifies as formal aligning with UNESCO’s strategy of peace education through schooling because of its qualifying traits. Some people argue school system. The first topic to be addressed is whether an that African indigenous education should not be classified as indigenous schooling system existed prior to the entrance of formal and should instead be considered informal. Osaat and Western prototype school. The answer is obviously yes, from Asomeji,32 for example, suggested that African indigenous the author’s perspective as a Basotho cultural insider; there education is informal in character as learning experiences are was, and still is, the existence of an indigenous Basotho conducted orally and knowledge is stored in the heads or schooling system in the form of lebollo. However, the literature minds of elders. It is primarily oral and does not exist in is inconsistent or does not provide a straightforward ‘yes’ to printed form. this problem. The misunderstanding may be exacerbated by the fact that, other than mophato, there is no actual institution The author advocated engaging in formal–informal debate in indigenous Basotho society that is referred to as a ‘school’. based on critical interculturality precepts. Santos19 proposed Lebollo is the term used to describe the activities at mophato. the concept of the interepistemic interculturality that stems According to Machobane,24 mophato is an initiation lodge, and from the realisation that historical colonialism did not lebollo is an initiation procedure. Therefore, mophato is a only include the wilful eradication of other civilisations in location where candidates, often youngsters, are initiated the process of indigenous cultural genocide. Instead, there into the mysteries of Basotho culture and adult life. was also a deliberate destruction of indigenous knowledge Machobane’s approach is more ritualistic than educational, systems, which Santos19 referred to as ‘epistemicide’ or with an emphasis on initiation ceremonies. Also, Matobo, the destruction of colonised populations’ knowledge Makatsa and Obioha25 depicted lebollo as a rite of passage from construction and deprivation of their modes of knowledge adolescence to maturity. Others, however, have categorised it transmission. According to Granados-Beltrán,33 epistemic as a school because of the fact that lebollo is active in interculturality represents ‘an-other’ or ‘border thinking’, educational activities and problems. Ngale,26 for example, which refers to oppositional indigenous thinking that is classified it as a traditional initiation school. Because the term seeking sociohistorical structural transformation rather than ‘initiation’ is usually associated with rites of passage rather acceptance or inclusion. Similarly, indigenous knowledge than education,27 the author suggested referring to mophato systems, according to Granados-Beltrán,33 do not seek to and lebollo as the Basotho indigenous schooling system where operate as a separate paradigm outside of modern dominant circumcision is taught as part of health and sex education structures. Rather, they enter those structures to suggest rather than performed as a rite. The author’s proposal is alternative thinking that affects and decolonises those in agreement with Letseka28 which refers to lebollo as the hegemonic paradigms in order to shatter the cultural schooling system with a systematic educational programme. standardisation that underpins Western universal knowledge structures but which fails to offer comprehensive solutions to Two related characteristics are used to categorise lebollo as an problems affecting indigenous people. Walsh20 pointed out indigenous schooling system. The first point to consider is that while interculturality has a different rationale from how schooling is defined or characterised. Secondly, what is colonialism, it also works outside the ancestral limits that the point of schooling? In different viewpoints, the schooling existed prior to colonisation. Hence, one may say that Basotho system is described differently. However, in this study, the indigenous education is neither formal nor informal but author used Goslin’s29 definition, which claims that schooling rather a context-specific education rooted in ancestral is an organised process of cultural transmission from one knowledge but applied in a modern context. As a support for generation to the next. Saldana30 adds that schooling is the education, which is context specific, Matambo34 asserted that official or formal method through which a society’s culture is theories of education must reflect the society in which it handed on to its offspring. Goslin29 defined culture as occurs. There are differing social, economic, cultural and cognitive systems, skills, beliefs and values, whereas formal religious circumstances that require different types of or organised refers to a condition in which an activity is no education. The concept of indigenous education takes into longer individualised or family based, but rather community account the cultural and scientific background of the or societally based. Related to cultural transmission is the indigenous people in the present context. http://www.td-sa.net Open Access Page 5 of 10 Original Research The case for peace-building through education programs.39 Traditional leaders representing lebollo indigenous education seem to be thankful for the recognition that they have received for their health education and practice; as one leader As stated in the introduction, several issues support the noted, ‘To make a new loin cloth, you use old pieces and add argument for peace education through the lebollo education new ones’, which suggests a need to build on old knowledge system. The first step is to target a large number of out-of- when introducing new strategies.39 According to Bulled,40 school adolescents who are excluded from conventional traditional leaders in Lesotho viewed the government Western education. According to Makatjane, Hlabana and approach as more empowering as it recognises and values Letete,35 10 000 young men attended indigenous Basotho the role of lebollo health education in reducing HIV infections. schools every year. While this number may include candidates with basic and tertiary Western education, Integrated Therefore, lebollo values the interculturality of biomedical Regional Information Networks News (IRIN)36 found that (objectivity) and indigenous circumcision (subjectivity) the bulk of trainees attending lebollo schools are primary and health practices in the fight against HIV transmission. The secondary school dropouts. As reported by Liphoto,12 the acceptance of coming into an agreement with the government Ministry of Education and Training recorded that 825 primary indicates tolerance and solidarity in lebollo, despite the fact school dropouts and 600 secondary school dropouts attended that, as Bulled40 highlighted, Western-educated elites are lebello schools in 2018. Malefetsane Liau, chairperson of the continually disgusted by lebollo. Western-educated elites see Council of Traditional Healers and one of the country’s most themselves as part of a rapidly modernising society, and their well-known herbalists, noted that lebollo provided boys education status distinguishes them from others who with an awareness and appreciation of their culture that participate in cultural ceremonies and practices. Although the conventional schooling system could not deliver.36 the lebollo schooling system welcomed the government’s Incorporating peace education within the lebollo curriculum invitation, this does not imply a willingness to submit would be a responsive technique for out-of-school youngsters. indigenous practices to the regulating institutions of Western The implication is that by including out-of-school youth, culturally oriented elites. During conversations concerning peace-building education would not just be an educational the potential incorporation of biomedical information in activity but an act of building peace by overcoming the lebollo, one traditional practitioner cautioned against ‘the divide between Western schooling and the indigenous incursion of governmental influence into a realm where some schooling system. The response would be in line with the of society’s poorest and most marginalised attempt to keep a critical interculturality proposition, as Santos19 realised that it limited hold on power’ (p. 87).40 She indicated that lebollo consists of developing (whenever appropriate) new forms of graduates are those with few marketable talents and few cultural understanding and intercommunication that may be opportunities to show power or position. As the region useful in favouring interactions and strengthening alliances becomes more connected to global markets, these people will among oppositional social institutions of different cultural have limited access to any alternative currency that they can contexts. Overcoming cultural divide through peace-building easily convert into coinage of the current liberal capitalist education would indeed be cherishing interculturality, which order. Subsequently, ‘tradition’, which the state risks is explained by Walsh17 to be a process of moving from an devaluing further, is perceived as a finite currency to exclusionary state towards an inclusive pluricultural country exchange for power.40 Guilherme’s41 concept of critical that integrates different sectors of society in any social, interculturality supports traditional leaders’ point that the political and cultural initiatives. Culturally inclusive peace- existence of multiple cultures as autonomous entities, building education, borrowing from Walsh,17 serves as a albeit heterogeneous in essence, should focus on the spaces transition from focusing on the dominant elitist group to in-between, that is, on their dialogical interaction, the elastic focusing on all members of society, and it gradually heals the nature of cultural identities and the dynamics of intercultural scars of inequality and cultural needs, guaranteeing collective encounters. As a result, reservations and expectations from responsibility in the efforts of peace-building. the two dialoguing groups must be respected in this sensitive and delicate encounter. Interculturality does not necessarily The most important point is that there are some lebollo imply fading into hybridisation or transculturality; rather, it elements that are compatible with peace-building education. denotes the establishment of critical interepistemic and In the first place, UNESCO37 and Navarro-Castro and decolonial interactions while acknowledging on-going Nario-Galace38 highlighted that building a culture of peace struggles for social and cognitive justice. It entails entails the promotion of intercultural understanding, reintroducing indigenous knowledge and traditions that tolerance and solidarity. Although lebollo is entirely a cultural have been rendered invisible and unheard. It pertains to institution providing ancestral-oriented education, it is capturing and articulating the knowledge, behaviours and always open to tolerate and work in solidarity with modern beliefs of the population that constitute the majority in terms demands for the betterment of Basotho society. For example, of numbers despite being the minority in terms of power.41 in recognition that male circumcision reduces human Therefore, the viability of lebollo for peace-building education immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection by at least 60%, does not necessarily entail its annihilation or consent to Lesotho took a dialogical initiative to involve lebollo, as it subjugation but rather a dialogic approach that acknowledges already incorporated circumcision into its health and sex lebollo’s ongoing colonial cultural resistance. http://www.td-sa.net Open Access Page 6 of 10 Original Research Lebollo schooling and peace- skills such as tenacity, tolerance and selflessness are instilled building education through the deprivation technique, in which students are sometimes left stranded without basic necessities such as It is advocated in this article that peace-building education be shelter, water and food while being expected to be even more introduced using the lebollo pedagogy. Lebollo pedagogy is an thoughtful and vigilant. indigenous Basotho pedagogy that, according to Burney’s42 definition of indigenous pedagogy, refers to a broad-based Borapedi (spirituality) is at the heart of lebollo education. education philosophy, practice and reflection of the Other in Students are taught the value of their indigenous belief society, life and all aspects of representation in socio-economic systems and the necessity of religion in sustaining their and political life. It is pedagogy which symbolises a program, identity and connecting them with all created beings. a strategy and education that is interdependent and According to Gill,22 the belief in the relationship between the connected with the culture and history of the Other and the living and the dead is important to Basotho religion, which indigenous. Lebollo pedagogy is founded on Basotho postulates the ancestors’ continuous engagement in the philosophy of education, teaching and learning practice and affairs of the living, whose physical, material and moral well- Basotho cultural life. It reflects the planned educational being is their concern. Students are taught how to maintain activities that stem from ancestral knowledge and have the good relations with their ancestors in order to gain ancestral ability to meet the demands of Basotho society in the past, support. To acquire ancestral protection and blessings, the present and future. living must follow certain moral standards and undertake particular social processes (including lebollo itself) that allow Lebollo pedagogy adheres to the epistemic principles of them to achieve botho (fuller humanity) and seriti (spiritual holism and communalism.43 Holism refers to the different strength). According to Maharasoa and Maharaswa, 44 elements that comprise the self, which include intellectual, safeguarding national secrets (makunutu a sechaba) referred to spiritual, emotional and physical components. Holism also keeping lebollo activities secret as vital to moulding a people, refers to a method of teaching and learning that does not distinguishing it from others through what is taught in lebollo. separate learning experiences into subject areas, as Western Keeping lebollo secrets is regarded as the highest moral norm, education does.43 ’s pedagogy allows students to as it preserves Basotho identity. It protects the nation’s Lebollo uniqueness and the importance of what makes Basotho reflect on the four dimensions of knowledge: (1) emotional, who they are against modern dilution and total mental (2) spiritual, (3) cognitive and (4) physical learning experiences. colonisation. According to Maharasoa and Maharaswa44 and Letseka,28 instruction and learning activities at lebollo are aimed Communalism is another epistemic assumption that at developing holistic interrelated competencies such as underpins lebollo education. African communalist bohloeki (purity), thuto-kelello (cognition), makhabane (virtues), epistemology emphasises that people cannot achieve their borapedi (spirituality [national unity and respect for social human attributes on their own or by themselves. Their structures]). Of course, there are other competencies, but the accomplishments are not dependent on willpower, memory ones described above are more relevant to peace-building or intellect, but rather on relationships with other people. education. Shutte45 explained that the concept of self is not anything inside a person or one’s mental characteristics or strength; it Purity or cleanliness (bohloeki) refers to the ability to maintain is something outside, derived from one’s relationships with mental, emotional and spiritual purity, that is, to think others and the world order. The individual can only say, ‘I carefully, to be pure in heart and spirit. These skills are am, because we are, and since we are, therefore I am’ (p. 41),45 created via the telling of folktales.44 Critical thinking or ‘I am related, so I am, not I think, so I am’ (p. 54).46 This development promotes cognitive functionality by allowing expression is found in the Sesotho saying, ‘motho ke motho students to debate history and poems connected to the ka batho ba babang’, meaning a person is a person only socio-economic and political lives of the society. Critical through others. Consequently, lebollo uses a variety of thinking is intended to improve reasoning skills for the instructional strategies to instil communal values in the khotla (a traditional judicial and parliamentary institution) students. The seclusion approach, according to Magesa,47 is deliberations. The technique is a problem-based education, itself a planned psychological procedure in which students in which students are required to solve problems that are are isolated from their community in order to withstand representative of the community’s real life environment.44 physical and psychological constraints meant to instil a sense Hard effort, respect for all, humility, perseverance, tolerance, of collective yearning. As a result of their disengagement, the service to one’s homeland and patriotism are all emphasised students are trapped. Their sense of belonging is snatched in the lebollo curriculum. According to Maharasoa and from them. In this approach, they are taught to desire Maharaswa,44 there are two instructional strategies for connectedness to family and community while also being developing healthy moral behaviour. The first is aware of the perils of individuality. Communal competencies role-modelling, in which instructors are selected based on are also developed through the pedagogy of lebollo. According their strong moral standing in the community, as well as their to Maharasoa and Maharaswa,44 there is continuous substantial political, economic and social status. Students are integrated learning and assessment meant to identify each influenced to want to be like them. Emotional intelligence person’s strengths and weaknesses. The term ‘assessment’ http://www.td-sa.net Open Access Page 7 of 10 Original Research refers to the process of describing the areas in which students to UNESCO, teaches peace values and virtues such as best display their abilities. The students are assigned names compassion, friendliness, humaneness, sharing, respect and associated with their talents and skills (a form of caring, which lead to more descriptive terms of human action specialisation), which they must demonstrate in the such as empathy, hospitality, dignity, harmony, humility, community after completion of training. Examples are Lenepa forgiveness, responsibility, order, understanding, helping (the exact one), Leteba (the one who goes in depth) and Letsitsa and peace creation. (the stable one). Lebollo graduates possess a clear sense of social responsibility aligned to their area of specialisation.44 Although lebollo and conventional peace education have a meeting point, this does not mean that the two are identical In light of this Basotho philosophy of education, it is clear or that one is submitting to another. As Monyela55 pointed that lebollo pedagogical approaches and international peace- out, in the lebollo education system, peace competencies are building education are inextricably linked. Starting with cultivated through torture, corporal punishment and inflicted holistic pedagogy, it is clear that authors in peace-building sacrifices. For example, trainees undergo physical training to education such as Mondal and Ghanta,48 Singh49 and overcome difficulties and pain in order to cultivate courage, UNESCO50 appeared to follow the definition of peace endurance, perseverance and obedience. Maharsoa and 44 education offered by Schmidt and Friedman51 that ‘peace Maharaswa further added that students at lebollo are often education is holistic’. It emphasised the physical, emotional, deprived of basic needs such as food, water, sleep and intellectual and social development of children within a affection, while they have to stay focused on the cause and system of values based on the traditional human values. think strategically about what needs to be done. Additionally, 39 Schmidt and Friedman’s holistic approach to peace education Bullied concurred that students at the lebollo school are leaves out the element of spirituality, but Magro52 argued that subjected to physical hardships, including nakedness in the for a comprehensive, transformative peace-building education, winter, beatings, starvation, torture and harassment and learning cannot be compartmentalised and viewed solely suffering the pain and complications associated with from a cognitive perspective but must include a spiritual circumcision surgery. In contrast, mainstream peace-building dimension. Learning, from a spiritual standpoint, does not education is said to be supported by a peaceful, safe and merely concern the intellect, but all aspects of human welcoming learning environment. According to UNESCO, 2 factors that threaten a safe learning environment include existence, including the physical, emotional, aesthetic and 53 those related to physical safety, such as corporal punishment; spiritual. Meyerhof defined spirituality as a dynamic those related to emotional safety, such as bullying and process of consciousness and as a path of evolution which manipulation; those related to environmental safety, such as brings humans closer to themselves, the planet, their larger properly constructed schools, attacks, conflicts and natural cosmos and the eternal source of all that is. According to disasters; cognitive safety threats, such as malnutrition and Meyerhof,53 tapping into the spiritual dimension through indoctrination; and spirituality safety threats, such as a lack peace education allows people to feel connected, of spaces for silence and reflection. These factors are present interconnected and aligned with all humanity, animals, in lebollo, but UNESCO views them as incompatible with nature, economy and cosmos, leading to ethical, holistic and peace-building education. responsible thinking and acting beyond all personal, national, ethical or religious boundaries. However, as previously indicated, the meeting point does not always refer to the sameness, but to the sameness in Lebollo’s communalist approach to teaching and learning difference. Drawing on interculturality theory, Walsh20 appears to be replicated in UNESCO’s conventional peace- warned that the goal of indigenous pedagogy is to strengthen building education. Communalism is synonymous with and position the features of other epistemological logic, logic botho in Sesotho and ubuntu in Nguni. Swanson54 asserted that is not always based on equality among education that ubuntu is an expression of the philosophy that an systems. It is not intended to bring indigenous education up individual’s strength comes from community support and to the level of popularity of Westernised schooling or to open that dignity is achieved as a result of openness, empathy, up Westernised schooling to include indigenous education generosity and commitment, all of which foster a journey systems. Dr Letsie, a Western-educated doctor and proponent towards becoming human. According to Swanson,54 ubuntu of lebollo, underlined this argument at a consultation forum epistemology is a mode of knowing that encourages a path on male circumcision and HIV prevention hosted by the towards becoming human in a community of humans. It is an Government of Lesotho in 2006. Letsie argued that, while indigenous philosophy of ways of knowing (epistemology) traditionalists welcome the government’s acknowledgement and being (ontology). The African epistemology of ubuntu of lebollo’s contribution to HIV prevention, lebollo should not focuses on human relations by addressing people’s moral be confused with mainstream HIV medical male circumcision and spiritual conceptions of what it means to be human and (MMC). Letsie remarked that, while they are willing to adopt to have a relationship with the other. The United Nations the Ministry of Health’s proposed safe operation, lebollo Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization1 affirmed activities remain secret, and that concealment has been and ubuntu pedagogy as a learning philosophy that may lead to continues to be an important component of the liberation the development of interconnectedness and interdependence struggle against colonialism.39 Indeed, as a school and among humans. The ubuntu educational approach, according cultural institution, lebollo serves as a base for colonial http://www.td-sa.net Open Access Page 8 of 10 Original Research resistance. During colonialism, Emile Ronald, a colonial than ‘making up’ or ‘getting along’ but a serious government official in Lesotho, designated lebollo as a centre reconsideration of the totality of relationships to other. of colonial resistance in a report on the status of administration. Decolonisation involves profound transformations of self, According to Rolland: community and social institutions. It means dismantling [T]he rules and character of this institution, as well as its symbolic colonial constructions of differences while reimagining and language understood only by the initiated, render it particularly rebuilding practices and institutions for the betterment of fit to be the means of a secret and conspiracy, and as long as it all. Considering the need for lebollo to be transformed and exists it will form a dead barrier to all improvements, and form a become an urgent of transformation, at HIV and AIDS dangerous engine capable of being set against the government … MMC consultation, Dr Letsie (a self-claimed custodian of This institution should be at once put down by proclamation, as lebollo) noted that lebollo was part of the liberation struggle a custom tending to immorality and dangerous to good against colonialism and that this struggle could be governance … This silly distinction conferred by [lebollo] will reoriented for liberation against the HIV scourge. Dr Letsie thereby disappear, and the ground taken away for jeer, for which argued that if lebollo were to be incorporated into the the black man in his own estimation considers himself to be 56 mainstream HIV prevention, it would have to be purged of superior to white. (p. 135) certain elements and be modified to conform to the 21st- 39 Identifying lebollo as a cultural entry point for mainstream century requirements. This means that the transformation peace-building education necessitates taking into account the of lebollo for peace education should come from within reality that the two are distinct, one from hegemonic culture rather than being imposed from without in order to conform and the other from resistance culture. Lebollo’s continued to Western peace-building education, thus maintaining resistance is evidence that internal colonialism has made colonial policy. subservient the Basotho and their indigenous school system within their own country. Therefore, mainstreaming peace Conclusion education into indigenous school systems requires a very This article proposes expanding peace-building education conscious approach. Based on their experience of Australian beyond the formal schooling system to encompass indigenous schools, Biemann and Townsend-Cross57 warned that education, primarily lebollo education. Lebollo is identified as indigenous systems of education are often used to achieve an ideal for expanding peace-building education in Lesotho. mainstream educational goals. They are often subsumed into Those involved in peace-building education should seek the canon of established Western parameters, which result in ways to work with the administrative bodies that oversee the them being dismembered and reassembled to fit into the nation’s lebollo education system, such as the traditional Western paradigm. In the view of Biermann and Townsend- leaders (marena), the high-ranking members of the National Cross,57 this strategy is in fact structural violence, as it Council of Culture and Heritage (Lekhotla la Mekhoa le Meetlo, introduces indigenous education in a manner that caters to LMM), traditional healers (lingaka tsa Sesotho) and the the interests of the Western educational system while National Initiation School Committee. The government, as maintaining the methodological and conceptual parameters the principal stakeholder, should encourage dialogue in of the Western educational system. In order to teach peace- order to establish a peaceful framework for the teaching and building through lebollo, it is prudent to explore the learning of peace in the lebollo school system. Three issues opportunities offered by critical interculturality. As Walsh17 argues, critical interculturality demands a dramatic shift in may hinder the government from leading the charge to the prevailing order, which is the foundation of Western introduce lebollo into the public space. In the first place, modernity, as well as the continuation of colonial power. It cooperation with lebollo instructors and traditional healers develops a conceptual understanding of the lived legacies of could indicate that the Lesotho government supports lebollo. colonisation, oppression, exclusion and colonial difference, For years, the Lesotho government has distanced itself from as well as the manifestation of these legacies in social cultural rituals such as lebollo as a means of developing structures and institutions, including education. Accordingly, Lesotho into a Christian, democratic and modern nation. it strives to reform, reconceptualise and reimagine systems Secondly, lebollo faces criticism from various social groups, and institutions in ways that bring contradictory, different particularly faith-based organisations such as World Vision, cultural logics, practices and ways of thinking, acting and which is vociferous in its opposition to lebollo, accusing it of living into balance. Interculturality, in this view, is an ongoing increasing school dropouts and child marriage. Thirdly, in and active process of negotiation and interaction that does 2004, the government attempted a top-down initiative not eradicate difference. Instead, it aims to foster new through legislation to regulate and institutionalise lebollo. understandings, coexistences, solidarities and joint efforts The motion was withdrawn even before it could be presented between communities.17 to Parliament. Members of parliament who attended lebollo feared that discussing delicate Basotho culture with people While lebollo maintains its stance of colonial resistance, it also who opposed it would betray it (in other words, to betray the engages in the decolonisation process of creating new resistance to colonialism). Nonetheless, a nonviolent strategy possibilities for new social orders founded on peaceful devoid of colonial violence and based on mutual respect can principles of life, fulfilling for all. As Biermann and bring lebollo on board for peace-building education, just as it Townsend-Cross57 presupposes, decolonisation implies more happened in response to the HIV and AIDS pandemic. http://www.td-sa.net Open Access Page 9 of 10 Original Research Acknowledgements 18. Fleuri RM, Fleuri LJ. Learning from Brazilian indigenous peoples. Aust J Indig Educ. 2017;47(1):8–18. https://doi.org/10.1017/jie.2017.28 Competing interests 19. Santos B. Epistemologies of the South and the future. From the European South [homepage on the Internet]. 2016 [cited 2021 Dec 05]. Available from: http:// europeansouth.postcolonialitalia.it The author has declared that no competing interest exists. 20. Walsh C. ‘Other’ knowledges, ‘Other’ critiques: Reflections on the politics and practices of philosophy and decoloniality in the ‘Other’ America. Transmodernity. 2012;1(3):11–27. https://doi.org/10.5070/T413012880 Author’s contributions 21. Walsh C. Shifting the geopolitics of critical knowledge: Decolonial thought and cultural studies ‘others’ in the Andes. Cult Stud. 2007;21(2):224–239. http://doi. R.I.M. is the sole author of this research article. org/10.1080/09502380601162530 22. Gill SJ. A short history of Lesotho. Morija: Morija Museum & Archives; 2010. Ethical considerations 23. Matŝela ZA. The indigenous education of the Basotho and its implications for educational development in Lesotho [Doctoral dissertations]. Boston, MA: University of Massachusetts; 1979. This article followed all ethical standards for research without 24. Machobane LBBJ. Missionary practice and the African reaction: A case of Barolong direct contact with human or animal subjects. and Basotho in the nineteenth century. In: LBBJ Machobane, TL Manyeli, editors. Essays on religion and culture among Basotho. Maseru: Mazenod Publishers, 2001; p. 127–151. Funding information 25. Matobo TA, Makatsa M, Obioha EE. Continuity in the traditional initiation practice of boys and girls in contemporary Southern Africa Society. Stud Tribes Tribals, 2009;7(2):105–113. https://doi.org/10.1080/0972639X.2009.11886600 This research received no specific grant from any funding 26. Ngale IF. Lebollo as a Basotho indigenous knowledge framework for human and agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors. organizational flourishing. J Anthropol Archaeol Sci. 2021;4(2):475–481. https:// doi.org/10.32474/JAAS.2021.04.000181 27. Mabena, David Khuwa. The role of initiation schools in the identity formation of Data availability Southern Ndebele adolescent boys [Masters dissertation]. University of South Africa; 1999. Data sharing is not applicable to this article as no new data 28. Letseka, M. Educating for Ubuntu/Botho: Lessons from Basotho indigenous education. Open J Philos. 2013;3(2):337–344. https://doi.org/10.4236/ were created or analysed in this study. ojpp.2013.34a005 29. Goslin DA. The function of the school in modern society. In: S Foreman, editor. The school in contemporary society. Arlington, VA: American Institute of Research, Disclaimer 1965; p. 1–10. 30. Saldana J. Power and conformity in today’s schools. Int J Humanit Soc Sci. The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of 2013;3(1):228–232. the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or 31. Hakim-Larson J, Menna R. Acculturation and enculturation: Ethnic identity socialization processes. In: MM Amer, GH Awad, editors. Handbook of Arab position of any affiliated agency of the author. American psychology. London: Routledge, 2016; p. 34–47. 32. Osaat SD, Asomeji AI. The philosophical bases for African indigenous education: Implications for Nigerian education. J Qual Educ. 2017;13(1):1–7. References 33. Granados-Beltrán C. Critical interculturality: A path for pre-service ELT teachers. Íkala Revista de Lenguaje y Cultura. 2016;21(2):171–187. http://doi.org/10.17533/ 1. Galtung, J. ‘Three approaches to peace: Peacekeeping, peacemaking and udea.ikala.v21n02a04 peacebuilding’. Impact Sci Soc. 1976:1/2(25–29):282–461. 34. Matambo, E. Formal against indigenous and informal education in sub-Saharan 2. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. Transformative Africa: The battle without winners. Indilinga Afr J Indigenous Knowledge Systems. pedagogy for peace building: A guide for teachers. Addis Ababa: UNESCO-IICBA; 2018;17(1):1–13. 2017. 35. Makatjane T, Hlabana T, Letete E. Male circumcision and HIV in Lesotho: Is the 3. Matlosa K. Pondering the culture of violence in Lesotho: A case for demilitarisation. relationship real or spurious? Analysis of the 2009 demographic and health J Contemp Afr Stud. 2020;38(3):381–398. https://doi.org/10.1080/02589001.202 survey. Maryland, MD: ICF International. 2016; p. 1–34. 0.1749246 36. Integrated Regional Information Networks News (IRIN). Boys quit school to 4. De Wet C. School violence in Lesotho: The perceptions, experiences and become men. The New Humanitarian [homepage on the Internet]. 2011 [cited observations of a group of learners. S Afr J Edu. 2007;(27):673–689. 2022 Jan 15]. Available from: https://www.thenewhumanitarian.org 5. Lekhetho M. The impact of free primary education on access and quality of 37. UNESCO. The culture of peace and UNESCO’s action. Paris: UNESCO; 1998. primary education in Lesotho. Int J Edu Sci. 2013;5(4):397–405. https://doi.org/1 0.1080/09751122.2013.11890101 38. Navarro-Castro L, Nario-Galace J. Peace education: A pathway to a culture of peace. Quezon: Center for Peace Education; 2010. 6. UNICEF. Lesotho education fact sheets 2021: Analyses for learning and equity using MICS data. Maseru: UNICEF Lesotho. 2021. 39. Ministry of Health. Report on male circumcision and HIV prevention country consultation meeting. Maseru: Ministry of Health; 2006. 7. UN. Declaration on a culture of peace. Paris: United Nations; 1999. 40. Bulled NL. New lives for old: Modernity, biomedicine, traditional culture and HIV 8. Navarro-Castro L, Nario-Galace J. Peace education: A pathway to a culture of prevention in Lesotho. Global Discourse. 2013;3(2):1–16. https://doi.org/10.1080 peace. Quezon City: Centre for Peace Education. 2010. /23269995.2013.804700 9. Ukpabi SC. Western education and African culture. Présence Africaine. 41. Guilherme M. The critical and decolonial quest for intercultural epistemologies 1970;(3):163–172. https://doi.org/10.3917/presa.075.0163 and discourses. J Multicult Discourses. 2019;14(1):1–13. https://doi.org/10.1080/ 10. Dungey CE, Ansell N. ‘I go to school to survive’: Facing physical, moral and 17447143.2019.1617294 economic uncertainties in rural Lesotho. Child Geogr. 2020;18(6):614–628. 42. Burney S. Toward a pedagogy of the other: Interculturalism, inclusiveness, https://doi.org/10.1080/14733285.2020.1822514 interdisciplinarity. Counterpoints. 2012;(417):195–208. 11. The World Bank in Lesotho. Country economic overview. The World Bank Lesotho [homepage on the Internet]. 2021 [cited 2022 Jan 05]. Available from: https:// 43. Morcom LA. Indigenous holistic education in philosophy and practice, with www.worldbank.org/en/country/lesotho/overview#1 wampum as a case study. Foro de Educación. 2017;15(23):121–138. https://doi.org/10.14516/fde.572 12. Liphoto N. Keeping an eye on initiation schools. Maseru: The Post 2022 Feb 15. 44. Maharasoa MMA, Maharaswa MB. Men’s initiation schools as a form of higher 13. The Central Bank of Lesotho. The economic impact of youth unemployment in education within the Basotho indigenous knowledge systems. 2004;18(3):106– Lesotho. Econ Rev. 2012;(148):1–8. 114. https://doi.org/10.4314/sajhe.v18i3.25484 14. Grist H. The Dennis Potter Heritage Project: Auto/Ethnography as process and 45. Shutte A. Philosophy for Africa. Cape Town: UCT Press (Pty) Ltd; 1993. product. eSharp [serial Online]. 2013 [cited 2021 Nov 28];(20):1–25. Available from: http://www.gla.ac.uk/media/media_279208_en.pdf 46. Bujo B. The ethical dimension of community. Nairobi: Pauline Publications Africa; 1998. 15. Ellis C, Adams TE, Bochner AP. Autoethnography: An overview. Hist Soc Res. 2011;36(4):273–290. https://doi.org/10.12759/hsr.36.2011.4.273-290 47. Magesa L. The moral: African traditional religion of abundant life. Nirobi: Pauline Publications Africa; 1998. 16. Anderson L. Analytic autoethnography. J Contem Ethnogr. 2006;35(4):373–395. https://doi.org/10.1177%2F0891241605280449 48. Mondal M, Ghanta B. Theoretical perspectives of peace education. Int J Res Anal Rev. 2018;5(3):1842–1847. 17. Walsh C. Interculturality and decoloniality. In: W Mignolo, C Walsh, editors. On decoloniality: Concepts, analytics, praxis. Durham: Duke University Press, 2018; 49. Singh K. Concerns of school in nurturing peace education. TechnoLEARN. p. 60–80. 2015;5(1–2):9–13. https://doi.org/10.5958/2249-5223.2015.00002.9 http://www.td-sa.net Open Access Page 10 of 10 Original Research 50. UNESCO. Learning the way of peace: A teachers’ guide to peace education. New 54. Swanson DM. Ubuntu: An African contribution to (re)search for/with a ‘humble Delhi: UNESCO; 2001. togetherness’. J Contem Issues Educ. 2007;2(2):53–67. https://doi.org/10.20355/ 51. Schmidt F, Friedman A. Peacemaking skills for little kids. Miami: Peace Education C5PP4X Foundation; 1988. 55. Monyela NC. The experiences of newly initiated Basotho men in selected 52. Magro K. Teaching for social justice and peace education: Promising pathways for Botshabelo High Schools, Free-State Province [Master’s Degree dissertation]. transformative learning. J Peace Res. 2015; 47(1/2):109–141. University of the Free State; 2017. 53. Meyerhof N. From peace education to education for spiritual peace building. 56. Rolland ES. ‘Notes on the political and social position of the Basotho tribe’. Federation of World Peace and Love [homepage on the Internet] 2016. [cited Lesotho Natl Arch. 1868;IV(1):125–151. 2022 Jan 16]. Available from: http://www.fowpal.org/peak-view/peace- 57. Biermann S, Townsend-Cross M. Indigenous pedagogy as a force for change. Aust education-education-spiritual-peace-building J Indig Educ. 2008;37(S1):146–154. https://doi.org/10.1375/S13260111 0000048X http://www.td-sa.net Open Access