Ecology and conservation of the butterfly Thestor brachycerus brachycerus (Trimen, 1883) from the Western Cape

Abstract

The 1883 discovery, research into generic life histories and taxonomic investigations into the aphytophagous butterfly Thestor brachycerus brachycerus (the Knysna Skolly) from Knysna, South Africa are described. Its slide towards extinction through loss and degradation of habitat in the late 20th century left only one known colony by 2009 leading to it being assessed as Critically Endangered in the 2013 South African Red List and Atlas. During searches for more populations in 2011, a second T. b. brachycerus colony was found which differed markedly with respect to aspect, altitude and vegetation. Study areas were defined around the original colony on the Pezula Golf Estate (Pezula) and the newly discovered coastal colony east of Coney Glen (Coastal site). An assessment is made of the ecological differences and similarities between the two sites. The extent and size of the two known populations was measured; the Extent of Occupancy was found to be 7.5 km2 and the Area of Occupancy as 1.05 x 10-3 km2. During observations over 5 seasons in December and January 2009 – 2014 the average number of butterflies observed at the original Pezula colony varied from 1 – 8 males and 0 – 3 females per survey, compared with 1 – 6 males and 1 – 3 females observed over 3 seasons from 2011 to 2014 at the Coastal colony. The mating, territoriality, oviposition and predation avoidance behaviour of the adult T. b. brachycerus butterflies was studied by direct observation. Males were found to exhibit territorial behaviour, spending long periods of time perched in one spot, particularly in areas where the vegetation was open or low. Oviposition was rapid and no preference was shown by females for any particular plant. Between the two colonies, oviposition was observed on a total of 16 different plants. The vegetation composition at the two study sites was analysed using Braun–Blanquet methodology. Only one plant, Tarchonanthus littoralis, was found to be common to both. There appeared to be no correlation between floristic composition and the occurrence of T. b. brachycerus. All the Thestor species so far studied by other workers have been found to be myrmecophilous, having an association with the pugnacious ant Anoplolepis custodiens. Ant communities were sampled by employing pitfall traps and direct sampling by hand. At both the Pezula and Coastal sites A. custodiens was the most ubiquitous ant species. The insights gained have enabled implementation of a habitat management plan. Experimental management methods are recommended at the Pezula site which include small scale burning and selective cutting of vegetation. Search for more colonies is ongoing, using the improved ecological knowledge of the butterfly.